Cheap Liability Car Insurance 2025: 7 Best Companies for Affordable Coverage
Cheap Liability Car Insurance is the most budget-friendly way to meet state requirements and protect yourself against financial liability for injuries or property damage you cause. In 2025, drivers are still paying widely different rates depending on company, state, driving record and available discounts.
This long-form report lays out the 7 best companies for affordable liability-only coverage, sample annual rates, regional winners, actionable savings tips, and a step-by-step comparison to help you lock in the cheapest liability car insurance for your needs.
What Is Liability Car Insurance?
Liability car insurance covers injuries and damages you cause to others when you are at fault in an accident. It does not cover damage to your own vehicle or medical costs for your injuries unless you carry additional coverages.
Core components
- Bodily Injury (BI) Liability: Pays other people’s medical bills and lost wages.
- Property Damage (PD) Liability: Covers repair or replacement of other people’s property, including vehicles.
Quick facts (numbered)
- Most states require minimum BI and PD limits, commonly expressed like 25/50/25 (thousand-dollar units).
- Liability-only policies are typically around 60% cheaper than full coverage policies.
- Liability-only is wise for older cars with low market value and for drivers prioritizing low monthly premiums.
Average Costs and Key Rate Drivers in 2025
The national average for liability-only car insurance sits near $829 per year (about $69 per month) for a typical 35-year-old driver with a clean record. Actual prices vary widely.
Factors that drive your premium
- Location: Urban vs. rural, state laws, and local claims frequency.
- Driving history: Tickets, accidents and at-fault claims raise rates.
- Vehicle: Age and value matter — liability-only is cheaper if your car is older and paid off.
- Credit score: Many insurers use credit-based insurance scores except where restricted.
- Discounts: Bundling, telematics, student discounts and military discounts lower premiums.
Top 7 Companies for Cheap Liability Car Insurance in 2025
Below are the seven insurers that consistently offered the most affordable liability-only coverage in 2025, balanced by service and discounts.
-
State Farm — Best Overall for Nationwide Coverage
Average Annual Rate: $661
Why State Farm: lowest among large national carriers, strong local-agent network, multiple discounts and telematics program (Drive Safe & Save).
-
USAA — Lowest Rates for Military Members
Average Annual Rate: $437
Why USAA: unbeatable pricing and top customer satisfaction, but eligibility is limited to the military community and their families.
-
Erie Insurance — Best Regional Value
Average Annual Rate: $516
Why Erie: strong regional pricing in 12 states + DC, excellent satisfaction scores, and a rate-lock feature that many customers value.
-
American Family — Competitive National Rates
Average Annual Rate: $751
Why American Family: competitive in many markets, good multi-policy discounts, and solid digital tools plus agent support.
-
Travelers — Reliable with Balanced Pricing
Average Annual Rate: $792
Why Travelers: balanced pricing, flexible policy options, and discounts for continuous coverage and hybrid/electric cars.
-
Geico — Best for Digital Convenience
Average Annual Rate: ~$797
Why Geico: excellent online quoting and claims experience, numerous discounts (students, federal employees), and strong mobile app.
-
Auto-Owners — Best Regional Choice
Average Annual Rate: $632
Why Auto-Owners: good regional pricing across 26 states, high customer satisfaction, and strong agent relationships.
Liability Car Insurance Rates by Company (Annual)
| Company | Annual Rate (USD) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| State Farm | $661 | Cheapest among large national insurers |
| USAA | $437 | Best for military community |
| Erie | $516 | Regional low-cost leader |
| American Family | $751 | Competitive national option |
| Travelers | $792 | Balanced pricing |
| Geico | ~$797 | Strong digital tools |
| Auto-Owners | $632 | Regional customer favorite |
| Progressive | $801 | Higher among majors |
| Nationwide | $1,024 | Higher priced |
| Allstate | $1,344 | Higher priced |
Regional Variations and State Examples
Rates vary dramatically by state. Below are representative examples of cheapest carriers in key states (annual rates):
| State | Cheapest Company | Annual Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Alabama | State Farm | $432 |
| California | Geico | $505 |
| Indiana | Auto-Owners | $424 |
| North Carolina | Erie | $353 |
| Ohio | Erie | $340 |
| Pennsylvania | Erie | $341 |
| Texas | Texas Farm Bureau | $404 |
Note: These figures reflect typical quotes for a 35-year-old driver with good credit and a clean driving record. Your quote will vary.
9 Practical Tips to Lower Your Liability Premium
- Shop annually: Price competition evolves — compare quotes once a year.
- Bundle policies: Combine home/renters and auto to unlock multi-policy discounts.
- Drive safely: A clean record is the single biggest driver of low premiums.
- Use telematics: Enroll in usage-based programs such as State Farm Drive Safe & Save or Geico DriveEasy.
- Increase deductibles: For collision/comprehensive you don’t carry in liability-only; but higher deductibles lower premiums if you carry partial coverage.
- Claim smart: Avoid small claims that could raise your rate.
- Lower mileage: Low-mileage discounts apply if you drive less than average.
- Good student discounts: Young drivers with good grades save money.
- Military discounts: If eligible, USAA and other carriers provide meaningful savings.
Liability-Only vs Full Coverage: Which Should You Choose?
| Coverage | What It Covers | Average Annual Cost (2025) | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liability-Only | Covers injuries/property damage to others (not your car) | $829 | Older/paid-off vehicles, budget-conscious drivers |
| Full Coverage | Liability + Collision + Comprehensive | $~2,150 | New or financed cars |
Deciding factor: if the replacement cost of your vehicle is low relative to the extra premium for full coverage, liability-only is usually the rational choice.
Customer Satisfaction & Service
In 2025, independent ratings consistently put USAA and Erie at the top for claims service and satisfaction. State Farm scores highly for local agent availability, while Geico is praised for digital convenience.
Final Verdict — Best Cheap Liability Car Insurance Companies (2025)
- State Farm — Best overall for most drivers nationwide.
- USAA — Best value for military families (eligibility required).
- Erie Insurance — Top regional pick with strong ratings.
- American Family — Reliable option with good discounts.
- Travelers — Balanced choice with flexible options.
- Geico — Great for fast online quoting and younger drivers.
- Auto-Owners — Personalized regional service and competitive rates.
Recommendation: Compare quotes from at least three carriers and confirm the exact liability limits required in your state before finalizing a policy.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. What is the cheapest liability car insurance company in 2025?
USAA posts the lowest average liability rate (~$437/year) but is limited to the military community. Among publicly available national insurers, State Farm is generally the cheapest overall (~$661/year).
2. Is liability-only car insurance enough?
For many drivers with older or low-value cars, liability-only is sufficient and cost-effective. It protects you from financial responsibility for others’ injuries and damages but does not pay to repair your vehicle or medical bills for you.
3. How much is liability car insurance per month?
On average, liability-only insurance is about $69 per month (approximately $829 per year). Your exact monthly payment depends on your personal risk factors and state.
4. Can I switch from full to liability-only mid-term?
Yes. Contact your insurer or agent to change coverages. Make sure the new policy still meets your state’s minimum legal requirements.
5. What discounts should I ask about?
- Multi-policy (bundle) discounts
- Telematics/usage-based discounts
- Good-student and low-mileage discounts
- Military or federal employee discounts
